- Fan Favorite – Charity Gayle – “Thank You Jesus For The Blood”
- Fan Favorite – Josiah Queen – “My Promised Land”
- Fan Favorite – Terrian – “He Sees You”
- Fan Favorite – Matthew West – “Unashamed”
- Fan Favorite – David Leonard – “God Of This Place”
- Fan Favorite – Elle Limebear – “Bye Fear”
- Fan Favorite – Bodie – “Whisper And The Wind”
- Fan Favorite – Jeremy Camp – “Again”
- Fan Favorite – Jordan St. Cyr – “To Save My Life”
- Fan Favorite – Patrick Mayberry – “Watch What God Can Do”
- Fan Favorite – Brandon Lake – “That’s Who I Praise”
- Fan Favorite – Seph Schlueter – “Running Back To You”
- Fan Favorite – Crowder – “Somebody Prayed”
- Fan Favorite – Megan Woods – “The Truth”
- Fan Favorite – Anne Wilson ft. Chris Tomlin – “The Cross”
- Fan Favorite – Hope Darst – “Hands of the Healer”
- Fan Favorite – Jordan Feliz – “Praise God For That”
- Fan Favorite – Riley Clemmons – “Jesus Cries”
- It’s A Tie! Fan Favorite – Josh Wilson – “It Gets Better” AND Sean Curran – “Led Me To You”
- Fan Favorite – Emerson Day – “God Ain’t Finished Yet”
- Fan Favorite – TobyMac – “Nothin’ Sweeter”
- Fan Favorite – Phil Wickham – “The Jesus Way”
- Fan Favorite – We The Kingdom – “Won’t He Do It”
- Future Fan Favorite – Sidewalk Prophets – Hurt People (Love Will Heal Our Hearts)
- Future Fan Favorite – Lauren Daigle – “Be Okay”
- Fan Favorite – Andrew Ripp – “Loves Got A Way”
- Fan Favorite – Unspoken – “What He Says About You”
- Fan Favorite – Tasha Layton ft. Chris Brown – “Worship Through It”
- Fan Favorite – David Leonard – “Keep The Light On”
- Fan Favorite – Hannah Kerr – “Changed”
- Fan Favorite – Tauren Wells – “Take It All Back”
- Fan Favorite – Josiah Queen – “The Prodigal”
- Fan Favorite – Brandon Lake – “Miracle Child”
- Fan Favorite – Rachael Lampa – “High Hopes”
- Fan Favorite – Evan Craft ft. Ke’Erron – “Chances”
- Fan Favorite – Danny Gokey – “I Got You”
- Fan Favorite – Josh Baldwin ft. Jenn Johnson – “Made For More”
- Fan Favorite – We Are Messengers – “God Be The Glory”
- Fan Favorite – Micah Tyler ft. Emerson Day – “People Like Us”
- Fan Favorite – Terrian – “Honestly, We Just Need Jesus”
- Fan Favorite – Leanna Crawford – “I Know A Place”
- Fan Favorite – Jeremy Camp – “These Days”
- Fan Favorite – Sanctus Real – “All Along”
- Fan Favorite – Matthew West – “Don’t Stop Praying”
- Most Voted On Future Fan Favorite From 2023 – Lauren Daigle – “These Are The Days”
- Fan Favorite – Crowder – “Grave Robber”
- Fan Favorite – Matthew West – “Because of Bethlehem”
- Fan Favorite – Tasha Layton – “Turn Your Eyes (This Christmas Day)”
- Fan Favorite – Evan Craft – “Someone Like Me”
- Fan Favorite – Chandler Moore/Todd Galberth – “Good News”
- Fan Favorite – Life.Church – “Thank You”
- Fan Favorite – Anne Wilson – “Strong”
- Fan Favorite – Ben Fuller – “If I Got Jesus”
- Fan Favorite – NEEDTOBREATHE – “Fall On Me”
- Fan Favorite – Seph Schlueter – “Counting My Blessings”
- Fan Favorite – Jeremy Rosado – “Come and See”
- Fan Favorite – Lauren Daigle – “These Are The Days”
- Fan Favorite – The Afters – “God Is With Us”
- Fan Favorite – Tauren Wells – “Crazy About You”
- Fan Favorite – Jordan Janzen – “You Can Let Go”
